What's better, an Automatic or a Manual Car?

Wondering whether your new car should be an automatic or a manual? It’s a common dilemma for many drivers. Whether you're drawn to the hands-on control of a manual gearbox or prefer the stress-free drive of an automatic transmission, both options offer their advantages and trade-offs.

In this article, we’ll help you decide which type of gearbox is right for you. We will highlight the key differences between automatic and manual cars and talk about what it is like to drive them.

What is the difference between manual vs automatic?

To put it simply, the main difference between a manual car and an automatic car is the type of gearbox fitted. A manual car has a manual gearbox operated by the driver, who coordinates moving the gear stick and using the clutch pedal.

An automatic car has an automatic gearbox. It does not have a clutch pedal (just an accelerator and brake pedal) and will change gears automatically depending on the speed at which the car is travelling, the load placed on the engine by the road gradient, or what is being carried and towed.

Can I drive a manual car with an automatic licence?

In the UK, to drive a manual car, you will need a manual licence (a driving licence with category B entitlement). If you pass your driving test in a manual car, you will receive a manual driving licence that allows you to drive both automatic and manual vehicles.

If you pass your driving test in an automatic car, you will receive an automatic driving licence (a driving licence with category B auto entitlement), which means you can only drive automatic vehicles. You cannot drive manual cars with an automatic licence.

Manual vs automatic: driving experience

When it comes to the driving experience, a manual transmission offers more control because the driver chooses exactly when to make a gear selection and can influence the driving experience in different ways with their clutch control.

On hilly or mountainous terrain, downshifting provides better control and power when going uphill. Similarly, if the driver is trying to be as economical as possible, manual transmissions give you the ability to change gears at lower engine speeds, improving fuel economy.

Automatic transmissions, on the other hand, can make driving significantly easier and more relaxing, especially in heavy traffic, stop-start traffic and for new drivers. By automatically selecting the optimal gear ratio for various driving conditions, autos eliminate the need for manual gear changes and the use of a clutch pedal. The introduction of dual-clutch gearboxes, some with paddle shifters behind the steering wheel, has also enabled a more sporty and engaging driving experience, the best of both worlds!

Manual vs automatic: fuel economy

In terms of fuel economy, a manual transmission can be more fuel-efficient than an automatic transmission, as it allows you to shift gears at the optimal engine speeds for maximum fuel efficiency. Thanks to advancements like dual-clutch transmissions and the addition of more gears, today’s automatic cars are far more fuel-efficient than their predecessors. In fact, many modern automatics now rival, or even outperform, manual vehicles when it comes to fuel economy.

That said, actual fuel consumption still depends on factors such as the vehicle’s make and model, engine type, and the specific transmission system used.

Are electric cars automatic or manual?

The majority of electric cars do not have a gearbox, as an electric motor can give high levels of torque from a standstill. This means the motor or motors are directly connected to the wheels, which simplifies the drivetrain, meaning fewer parts need to be maintained. Some high-performance electric cars do have a gearbox with a few gears, as this enables these vehicles to have both rapid acceleration and a higher top speed than comparable electric cars with no gearbox.

If you’re considering switching to electric, take a closer look at the new Torres EVX SUV.

Conclusion

Ultimately, it's personal preference on which transmission type you select; either way, you're guaranteed comfort, style and performance when choosing a KGM car. Ready to experience KGM vehicles for yourself? Book a test drive today or find your local Dealership.